Accountability

On-air predictions, tracked to the outcome

Hosts, analysts and callers make calls on air every day — rate cuts, reshuffles, title races. We extract the falsifiable ones from the broadcast transcript, wait for the horizon, and score them against public sources. Every call keeps its audio receipt.

graded
169graded
correct
57%correct
open
83open
close this week
3close this week
30 graded in the last 7 days →

45%

of 42 graded calls were right · this filter

19 correct23 incorrect

Graded means checked against a public source after the check-by date. Verdicts judge the claim, never the person: hosts, guests and callers all count.

Incorrect calls, newest first1–17 of 17

The verdict· graded 28 Sept

Australia beat South Africa 42-38 in Perth on 2026-09-27.

The verified passages all say Australia defeated South Africa in Perth on Sunday 27 September 2026, with scores of 42-38 or equivalent. That is the opposite of the prediction that Australia would lose.

Readers: 1 said yes, 0 said no

Craig Ray · Cape TalkAired 25 Sept

The verdict· graded 18 Sept

COSATU postponed its 15th National Congress amid leadership tensions, and the congress was still only taking place in Midrand on 2026-09-15.

The claim required the congress to make a decision on COSATU's voting posture for the 2026 local government elections by 2026-09-17. The evidence instead says the 15th National Congress was postponed, and the later report only shows the congress was taking place on 2026-09-15, not that it had made the stated decision. That means the predicted outcome is not established and the event does not appear to have concluded by the deadline.

The event so far

2 predictions from 2 stations

  1. Mon 31 Aug, 05:18Cape TalkThis one

    Matthew Parks

    Incorrect
  2. Correct
Matthew Parks · Cape TalkAired 31 Aug

The verdict· graded 17 Sept

The IEC certified 136,790 candidates for the 4 November 2026 local government elections on 16 September and said it would publish the final lists that day. (Corrected by the desk: the earlier explanation was an undecided draft.)

The claim was that the final candidate list would contain more than 100,000 candidates. The IEC certified 136,790, well above that, and said the lists would be published the same day. The reports give the certified total rather than quoting the published list itself.

The event so far

2 predictions from 2 stations

  1. Thu 27 Aug, 05:22702This one

    Sai Mamabolo

    Correct
  2. Incorrect
Sai Mamabolo · 702Aired 27 Aug

The verdict· graded 13 Sept

Antonelli won the first GP of Spain in Madring; Verstappen was 2nd and Norris 3rd.

The dated evidence from 2026-09-13 shows Antonelli first, Verstappen second, and Norris third, so Russell did not finish second as predicted. The undated Formula1.com result conflicts with the dated reports, but the dated passages establish the deciding outcome.

Avon Middleton · Cape TalkAired 12 Sept

The verdict· graded 13 Sept

South Africa won the 2026 series against New Zealand 3–1, sealing it with a 43–28 win in Baltimore on 12 September 2026. (Corrected by the desk: an earlier manual verdict graded the series off the first Test alone.)

The speaker said the All Blacks would win the series. New Zealand won the first Test 33–16 but lost the next three, so the series went to the Springboks 3–1.

The event so far

3 predictions from 2 stations

  1. Wed 12 Aug, 16:48Cape TalkThis one

    On air

    Incorrect
  2. Incorrect
  3. Correct

Readers: 1 said yes, 0 said no

On air · Cape TalkAired 12 Aug

The verdict· graded 13 Sept

South Africa beat New Zealand in Baltimore on 12 September 2026.

The prediction said the Springboks would not win, but the research notes say they did win that fourth Test. That makes the claim false regardless of the venue or date matching.

The event so far

3 predictions from 3 stations

  1. Correct
  2. Tue 8 Sep, 08:19Cape TalkThis one

    2 people called this · 1 yes, 1 no

    Incorrect

Readers: 0 said yes, 1 said no

A guest · Cape TalkAired 08 Sept

The verdict· graded 11 Sept

Coco Gauff did not win the 2026 US Open women’s singles title; Elena Rybakina beat her in the semifinal.

The claim required Gauff to win the title, but the research notes say she lost in the semifinal to Rybakina. Since she was eliminated before the final, the predicted outcome did not happen.

Readers: 0 said yes, 1 said no

Mawande Mattez · Cape TalkAired 31 Aug

The verdict· graded 06 Sept

Tadej Pogačar did not win the 2026 Vuelta a España; he abandoned the race on stage 8 after a crash, and Enric Mas was later the GC leader.

The prediction named Pogačar as the race winner, but the race outcome in the notes shows he withdrew on stage 8 and therefore could not win. The claim is settled against the speaker because the actual result diverged from the predicted winner, not just the margin or method.

John Pullman · Cape TalkAired 26 Aug

The verdict· graded 06 Sept

South Africa beat New Zealand 29–24 at FNB Stadium on 2026-09-05.

The claim says the Springboks would defeat the All Blacks in that third Test on that date and venue. The match was played and South Africa won 29–24, so the predicted outcome happened exactly as stated.

The event so far

8 predictions from 3 stations

  1. Incorrect
  2. Mon 31 Aug, 04:43702This one

    2 people called this · 2 yes, 0 no

    Correct
  3. Incorrect
  4. Correct
+3 more

Readers: 1 said yes, 0 said no

Custas · 702Aired 31 Aug

The verdict· graded 30 Aug

South Africa beat New Zealand 33-26 at DHL Stadium on 29 August 2026, leveling the series 1-1.

The prediction said New Zealand would defeat South Africa in the second test at DHL Stadium. The match result was the opposite: South Africa won 33-26 in that game, so the stated outcome did not happen.

The event so far

3 predictions from 2 stations

  1. Thu 27 Aug, 21:25Cape TalkThis one

    2 people called this · 2 yes, 0 no

    Incorrect
  2. Correct

Readers: 0 said yes, 1 said no

Jamie Wall · Cape TalkAired 27 Aug

The verdict· graded 24 Aug

Lando Norris won the 2026 Dutch Grand Prix at Zandvoort, George Russell finished second, and Charles Leclerc finished fifth.

The claim got the podium order wrong: Norris did not finish second, Russell did not finish third, and Leclerc did not win at all. The actual result had Norris first, Russell second, and Leclerc fifth, so the predicted finishing positions do not match the outcome.

Avon Middleton · Cape TalkAired 21 Aug

The verdict· graded 22 Aug

The All Blacks defeated the Springboks 33–16 on 2026-08-22 at Ellis Park in Johannesburg.

The claim got the winner wrong: it predicted a Springboks victory, but the All Blacks won instead. The date matched, but the result went the opposite way, with a 33–16 loss for South Africa.

The event so far

8 predictions from 2 stations

  1. Correct
  2. Mon 17 Aug, 12:59702This one

    2 people called this · 2 yes, 0 no

    Incorrect
  3. Incorrect
  4. Incorrect
+3 more

Readers: 4 said yes, 0 said no

A guest · 702Aired 17 Aug

The verdict· graded 17 Aug· weaker evidence

Reports from July 2026 described only partial Pikitup depot disruptions, and no reliable source confirmed that all depots were closed on 2026-08-14.

The claim said all Pick It Up depots would close on 2026-08-14, but the reports only showed partial depot disruptions and never confirmed a full shutdown on that date. That means the specific “all depots closed” prediction did not come true.

Temba Magwooda · Cape TalkAired 13 Aug

How this works: predictions are extracted by AI from machine-generated transcripts of live broadcasts (“as heard on air” — transcription errors are possible), and outcomes are resolved against public sources, linked on each card. Speakers are named only when the broadcast itself identifies them. This page records what was said and what happened. The reader poll is audience sentiment, not odds — no money is involved and there is nothing to wager on. Corrections: [email protected].